Thanks to Shaira for posting the actual rules from the book.
What Shaira posted from the book is different from what I expected based on the earlier comments in this thread. I assumed the rules in the book followed the more common BRP rule of "best degree of success wins; if both roll the same degree of success, the higher roll wins." That is what I would prefer. I understand why a crit vs a success should be less overwhelming than a crit vs a failure, but the genius of BRP has always been in its elegant simplicity, IMHO.
|